Coronavirus and Brexit talks are placing Scottish independence firmly again on the agenda ǀ View


Whether or not or to not pursue independence has lengthy been the predominant query in Scottish politics. It transcends almost each situation, together with Brexit. Whereas Scotland’s opposition to leaving the EU is well-known, Brexit itself has largely functioned as a automobile for the continuing independence debate.

Because it has in all places, the coronavirus pandemic, nonetheless, has additionally modified politics in Scotland. The standard independence dialog has been side-lined. The Scottish Authorities has, as an example, paused its work on making ready for a brand new potential referendum, and the governing Scottish Nationwide Celebration (SNP) formally suspended all associated campaigning.

The general public coverage response to the coronavirus has showcased the division of powers throughout the UK to a a lot wider extent than typical. Well being, schooling, and regulation and order in Scotland are all of the accountability of the Scottish Authorities, not the UK Authorities. However, this technique of devolution stays poorly understood in London.

Even all through the pandemic, the difficulty of independence by no means utterly disappeared. It has largely manifested itself by means of arguments over whether or not Scotland ought to align or diverge with England on coverage selections across the coronavirus lockdown, together with journey restrictions, reopening society, and social distancing recommendation. Some opponents of independence have advocated following the UK Authorities’s strategy, whereas supporters of independence have argued that Scotland ought to set its personal course.

Common politics have now begun to return considerably – prompted particularly by Brexit. The negotiations on the EU-UK future relationship are clearly in problem. Even when progress is made within the talks, the target of a free commerce settlement (FTA), plus cooperation in different areas, would make the UK essentially the most disconnected nation from the EU this aspect of the continent. However, the Scottish Authorities revealed a report arguing for the transition to be prolonged due to the coronavirus; the UK Authorities, nonetheless, stays dedicated to the unique timetable.

Now that the Brexit transition has not been prolonged, the independence debate ought to resume extra totally within the months forward. The first pre-pandemic focus of the Scottish Authorities had been to safe a brand new legally legitimate referendum by means of consensus with the UK Authorities. The primary minister, Nicola Sturgeon requested a switch of energy for one final December, nevertheless it was rejected by Boris Johnson. However, the primary minister had pledged to carry a referendum by the tip of this yr. The coronavirus ended that prospect – although it had appeared unbelievable in any case.

The SNP’s goal has been to comply with the precedent set by means of the primary independence referendum in 2014: a brief switch of authority to the Scottish Parliament for a authorized referendum and an settlement between the Scottish and UK Governments on the vote (together with implementing the end result). Given London’s unwillingness to debate these factors, the subsequent Scottish election is shaping as much as change into a defining second on whether or not a referendum will happen. That election is at present scheduled for Could 2021.

Independence will undoubtedly be the central situation in that election. In Scotland’s complicated politics, one of the crucial contested factors is what constitutes a “mandate” for a referendum. If the election produces a parliamentary majority in favour of independence, or certainly the SNP wins a majority (it’s at present a minority authorities), political and ethical stress will construct on the UK Authorities to facilitate a referendum. A professional-independence majority already exists within the Scottish Parliament, however a renewed election win can be a transparent democratic assertion.

Since 2016, the independence debate has been strongly formed by Brexit. In addition to obliging voters to decide on between the EU and the UK (since being a part of each is now not doable), it has additionally modified the idea of the dialog. An impartial Scotland’s path to EU membership and the Scotland-England border can be completely different within the post-Brexit context since Scotland and the remainder of the UK would search diverging relationships with the EU.

The coronavirus has introduced financial restoration and sustainability to the fore, which may even have an effect on the independence debate. Arguments about whether or not Scotland needs to be an impartial state have lengthy spanned themes past democracy or sovereignty. Financial and social insurance policies additionally characteristic, together with whether or not or not Scotland might obtain higher social outcomes with the complete powers of the State. As an illustration, some supporters of independence imagine that Scotland ought to undertake a Nordic social mannequin.

Opinion polls in current months have proven elevated assist each for independence and holding a referendum – and a number of other have produced small majorities for statehood. These will increase have largely been pushed by Boris Johnson as prime minister, the insurance policies of the Conservative authorities in London and the UK’s departure from the EU on the finish of January. It’s actually possible that assist for independence might proceed to develop. If the UK defaults out of its transition with no EU-UK settlement in December, extra voters could reassess their view of the UK union. Nonetheless, the event of the independence debate may even be essential.

Most of the individuals who have moved to assist independence – or are contemplating such a transfer – are pro-Europeans who had been in opposition to leaving the UK in 2014. Such voters are sometimes in search of reassurance that detailed pondering has been carried out on the main problems with debate. On the identical time, current supporters of independence have differing views on how quickly a referendum needs to be held or find out how to confront the UK Authorities’s refusal to interact. If these divisions should not well-managed, they might find yourself dissuading folks from backing independence by making a complicated image of what strategy can be taken.

Independence will finally make its full return to Scotland’s political dialog, and it’ll now be closely formed by each Brexit and the coronavirus. By means of these prisms, the upcoming Scottish election will show decisive in figuring out Scotland’s future route.

  • Anthony Salamone is Managing Director of European Retailers, a political evaluation agency primarily based in Edinburgh


Are you a recognised knowledgeable in your area? At Euronews, we imagine all views matter. Contact us at to ship pitches or submissions and be a part of the dialog.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here